Rediscover Your Lawn: A Comprehensive Review of the Earthwise Reel Mower

In an era dominated by technological advancements, there’s a unique satisfaction in returning to basics, especially when it comes to maintaining your home. For many homeowners, the simple act of mowing their lawn offers an unparalleled connection to their property. While gas-powered and electric mowers have their place, the classic reel mower offers an experience that is both timeless and increasingly relevant. It’s a return to a simpler, more mindful approach to lawn care, trailing only behind a scythe or perhaps a grazing animal in its straightforwardness.

This enduring tool is enjoying a significant resurgence, and at the forefront of this revival is the Earthwise Reel Mower. But why, in a world of smart devices and powerful engines, would you opt for a manual reel mower? To understand its appeal, we sought insights from an industry expert. Gene Cabellero, Co-Founder of GreenPal, a leading online platform for lawn care services, shared his expert perspective on the growing popularity of these eco-friendly alternatives.

“Reel mowers are an excellent choice for environmentally conscious homeowners because they don’t produce emissions like gas-powered mowers. They’re quieter, allowing lawn care without neighborhood disturbances. These mowers offer a cleaner cut by slicing the grass like scissors, promoting healthier lawn growth and reducing disease risk.”

— Gene Cabellero, Co-FOUNDER of GreenPal

What is the Earthwise Reel Mower and Why It’s Making Waves?

My first encounter with the Earthwise Reel Mower was serendipitous. A seemingly small package arrived, and for a few days, it sat innocuously on my kitchen table, mistaken for something else entirely. After a moment of frustration at its continued presence, I finally opened what I genuinely believed was a shoebox, only to discover a lawn mower within. Having recently endured the assembly nightmares of IKEA furniture and baby cribs, my initial reaction was to brace myself for an intricate, Lego-like construction challenge.

To my immense surprise, nothing could have been further from the truth. The box revealed just a few straightforward components that clicked together with remarkable ease. A quick turn of a knob, the use of a single Allen wrench, and sliding a couple of pieces into place – voilà! In mere minutes, the Earthwise Reel Mower was fully assembled and ready for action. This experience shattered my preconceptions about manual tools and their perceived complexity.

Once set up in my garage, my wife approached it with a simple, almost disbelieving, “That’s it?” Her question wasn’t judgmental but rather born of shock at the mower’s elegant simplicity. It was a tool that she instantly recognized as user-friendly, a sentiment she quickly confirmed by putting it to use herself. This ease of assembly and immediate usability are foundational to the Earthwise Reel Mower’s appeal.

Beyond its hassle-free setup, the Earthwise Reel Mower’s incredibly low price point is a major draw. The affordability often serves as the initial “hook,” but it’s the inherent simplicity and minimal ownership demands that keep users loyal. There’s no complex maintenance schedule to track, no worries about significant storage space, and certainly no expensive batteries to replace or gas to store. This machine embodies a “set it and forget it” philosophy, offering a truly refreshing alternative for homeowners seeking a low-stress, efficient lawn care solution year after year.

Why Embrace a Reel Mower? Beyond the Earthwise Model

The resurgence of reel mowers isn’t just a nostalgic trend; it’s a conscious choice driven by a blend of environmental awareness, economic sense, and a desire for a different kind of lawn care experience. Here are compelling reasons why more homeowners are turning to these manual machines:

• Environmental Stewardship: Reel mowers operate without any fuel or electricity, meaning zero emissions. This significantly reduces your carbon footprint, making them an ideal choice for the eco-conscious homeowner committed to sustainable living.
• Unmatched Quiet Operation: One of the most striking benefits is the sheer silence. Unlike the roaring engines of gas mowers or even the hum of electric models, a reel mower produces only the gentle whir of blades and the satisfying snip of grass. This allows for peaceful lawn maintenance without disturbing neighbors, enjoying conversations, or listening to music as you work.
• Superior Lawn Health: The cutting mechanism of a reel mower is fundamentally different. Instead of tearing or ripping the grass blades like rotary mowers, reel mowers create a clean, scissor-like cut. This precise action minimizes trauma to the grass, leading to healthier turf, less susceptibility to disease, and a vibrant, greener appearance. A clean cut also helps the grass retain moisture more effectively.
• Engaging Physical Activity: While they require some effort, reel mowing offers a gentle form of exercise. It’s an opportunity to get outdoors, engage physically with your environment, and enjoy the fresh air. This connection to the physical act of nurturing your lawn can be incredibly rewarding.
• Cost-Effectiveness and Low Maintenance: With no fuel costs, no oil changes, no spark plugs, and no charging batteries, the operational costs of a reel mower are virtually zero. Maintenance typically involves occasional blade sharpening and cleaning, making it an exceptionally budget-friendly option over its long lifespan.
• Durability and Longevity: Built with fewer complex parts, reel mowers are inherently more durable and less prone to breakdowns than their motorized counterparts. With proper care, a quality reel mower can truly last a lifetime.

Putting It to the Test: My Experience with the Earthwise Reel Mower

I dedicated an entire month to rigorously testing the Earthwise reel mower in my own backyard. Having evaluated over 30 different lawnmowers on this very same turf, I possess a unique comparative perspective across a wide spectrum of models and types. This extensive testing ground provided the perfect environment to assess the Earthwise’s performance against its motorized rivals.

There’s a persistent stigma surrounding reel mowers: the notion that they are incredibly difficult to push. Based on my extensive experience, I wholeheartedly disagree. While the very first push might require a slight initial effort, once the blades engage and momentum builds, the mower glides across the lawn with remarkable ease. The ingenious action of the rotating blades, combined with a gentle, consistent push, effectively carries the mower forward, making the experience far less strenuous than many imagine.

One of the most immediate and striking differences I observed was its weight. Fully assembled, this Earthwise reel mower tips the scales at just under 25 pounds. To put that into perspective, my gas-powered Honda mower weighs over 70 pounds. While a reel mower certainly requires kinetic force to slice through grass, the overall physical sensation and effort involved are surprisingly comparable to pushing a self-propelled gas mower, especially on a well-maintained lawn. The lighter weight also contributes significantly to maneuverability and ease of storage.

A common characteristic of push mowers, including reel models, is the absence of bagging options for clippings. For many, this might seem like a drawback, but in the realm of modern lawn care, it’s actually a significant advantage. I frequently advocate for the practice of “grasscycling”—allowing clippings to decompose on the lawn. These small pieces act as a natural fertilizer, returning vital nutrients and moisture to the soil, leading to a healthier, more resilient lawn over time. The Earthwise reel mower had a particularly satisfying way of flinging these finely cut clippings gracefully into the air, offering a visual testament to the work being done and confirming the effectiveness of each pass.

As previously mentioned, my wife also took the Earthwise for a spin, and both of us immediately noted its most remarkable feature: the ability to hold a normal conversation while mowing. Traditional mowers, even many electric models, produce an intense level of noise that necessitates ear protection. The Earthwise, however, operates in near silence. This peaceful quietude transforms lawn care from a noisy chore into a meditative activity, allowing you to enjoy the sounds of nature, listen to your favorite music, or engage in easy conversation as you cultivate your outdoor space.

Deep Dive into Earthwise Reel Mower Features

Understanding the specific features of the Earthwise Reel Mower helps illuminate why it stands out in a crowded market:

18-Inch Cutting Width: The Sweet Spot for Many Lawns

The Earthwise Reel Mower boasts an 18-inch cutting width, which is often considered the ideal size for small to medium-sized lawns. This width strikes a perfect balance: it’s broad enough to cover ground efficiently with each pass, reducing the number of strips you need to make across your yard. Yet, it remains narrow enough to maintain excellent maneuverability, allowing you to navigate around obstacles like trees, flowerbeds, and tight corners without undue effort or repetitive movements. In comparison, many gas-powered and electric push mowers with rotary blades typically range from 20 to 21 inches, though they can vary from 14 to 30 inches. The 18-inch width of the Earthwise ensures a manageable and precise cut, especially in residential settings.

Five Blades: Optimized for Performance

When it comes to reel mowers, the number of blades is a critical factor influencing cutting performance, and it’s essential to understand the implications before making a purchase. Simply put, more blades generally result in more cuts per pass, leading to a finer, closer trim. For warm-season grasses (such as Bermuda, Zoysia, or St. Augustine grass), which are typically maintained at a shorter height and demand a very precise, close cut, a higher blade count is beneficial. For these turf types, a reel mower with five to eight blades will deliver excellent results, ensuring that fine, manicured look.

Conversely, cool-season and transitional grasses (like Tall Fescue, Kentucky Bluegrass, or Perennial Ryegrass) are often kept at longer heights and don’t require the same “shave” as shorter warm-season varieties. For these grasses, fewer blades are generally sufficient. I would recommend a reel mower with three to five blades for cool-season varieties, as this configuration provides an effective cut without unnecessary complexity.

Straight Handlebar Design: Enhanced Control and Ergonomics

During my testing, I experimented with various reel mowers, including some equipped with T-shaped handles. I found that these designs often made it difficult to maintain precise control, leading to unintentional deviations and a less consistent mowing path. The Earthwise Reel Mower, however, features a robust, straight handlebar. This design significantly enhances control and stability, allowing for a more deliberate and straightforward pushing experience. The ergonomic benefits of a straight bar mean less strain and greater accuracy as you guide the mower across your lawn.

Integrated Rear Wheels for Height Adjustment and Storage: A Luxurious Detail

While many budget-friendly reel mowers omit this feature, the Earthwise comes equipped with additional wheels on the back. These wheels serve a dual purpose. Primarily, they facilitate effortless adjustment of the mower’s cutting height, allowing you to customize the length of your grass with ease. Beyond cutting precision, these rear wheels also play a crucial role in maintaining the mower’s balance, enabling it to stand upright independently. This is a significant convenience for storage, as it means the mower can be neatly tucked away in a garage or shed without leaning it against a wall, making it a surprisingly luxurious and practical bonus.

Pros of the Earthwise Reel Mower:

• Lightweight: Easy to push, maneuver, and transport.
• Inexpensive: Offers exceptional value for money compared to motorized alternatives.
• Quiet Operation: Enjoy peaceful lawn care without noise pollution.
• Low Maintenance: No engine, no fuel, minimal upkeep required.
• Completely Eco-Friendly: Zero emissions for a greener footprint.
• Promotes Healthier Lawn: Scissor-like cut is superior for grass health.

Cons of the Earthwise Reel Mower:

• Requires Physical Effort: While manageable, it demands more effort than self-propelled mowers.
• More Narrow: The 18-inch width means more passes for very large lawns.
• Best for Shorter Grass: May struggle with very tall or overgrown lawns.
• Not Ideal for Uneven Terrain: Works best on relatively flat surfaces.

Earthwise Reel Mower vs. Scotts Reel Mower: A Head-to-Head Comparison

The Earthwise reel mower and the popular Scotts reel mower both provide an effective 18-inch cutting experience, making them strong contenders in the manual mower category. However, they possess distinct differences that cater to varying lawn types and user preferences.

The Scotts mower distinguishes itself with a modified handle design that offers horizontal or vertical grip options, akin to bicycle handlebars. More significantly, the Scotts model typically features more blades than the Earthwise.

I generally recommend the Scotts mower for homeowners dealing with warm-season grasses. The increased blade count on the Scotts model (often seven or more) is particularly effective for achieving the very close, pristine “trim” that shorter, denser warm-season turf types demand. In contrast, the Earthwise, with its five blades, is an excellent choice for those with transitional and cool-season grasses. These grass varieties, such as Tall Fescue, are typically kept at a longer height and benefit from a slightly less aggressive cut, making the Earthwise perfectly suited for these zones, whereas the Scotts might be overkill for longer blades.

From a cost perspective, the Earthwise often presents a slightly more budget-friendly option compared to the Scotts reel mower. Ultimately, both are highly capable and commendable manual mowers. The choice between them largely depends on your specific grass type and preferred handling, with the Earthwise being superb for cool/transitional seasons and the Scotts often excelling in the deep South’s warm-season zones.

Final Verdict: Embrace the Earthwise Reel Mower Experience

My extensive testing and analysis lead me to enthusiastically recommend the Earthwise reel mower. It’s an outstanding choice for individuals with small to medium-sized lawns who are open to, and indeed desirous of, a more connected and simplified mowing experience. The Earthwise achieves a remarkable balance of affordability, ease of use, and effective cutting capability, culminating in a genuinely streamlined approach to lawn maintenance.

In a world that constantly pushes for more automation and less personal involvement, opting for a reel mower like the Earthwise is a conscious decision to get back to basics. It offers the profound satisfaction of connecting with your backyard through the honest effort of good old-fashioned elbow grease. This tangible engagement with your landscape fosters a sense of pride in your lawn that simply cannot be replicated by an exorbitantly priced machine or the impersonal touch of a professional landscaper. The Earthwise Reel Mower isn’t just a tool; it’s an invitation to cultivate a deeper appreciation for your outdoor space.

Where to Buy the Earthwise Reel Mower

The Earthwise reel mower typically ranges in price from around $100 to $140, though its cost can fluctuate based on ongoing sales and promotions. It frequently goes on sale on Amazon, which is where I sourced my model. It’s advisable to check various retailers for the best current deal.

Frequently Asked Questions About Reel Mowers

Who manufactures Earthwise mowers?

Earthwise mowers, along with several other lines of reel mowers, are proudly manufactured by the American Lawn Mower Company. This company has a long-standing history and reputation in producing reliable and effective manual lawn care equipment.

Which is better: Scotts or Earthwise reel mower?

In my comprehensive guide to the best reel mowers, I highlighted the Earthwise reel mower as an excellent choice, particularly for cool-season grasses and smaller, flatter lawns. The Scotts reel mower, on the other hand, is often recommended for warm-season grasses due to its higher blade count and robust design, which can also be beneficial for lawns with a gentle slope. It’s less about one being objectively “better” and more about which mower is better-suited to your specific lawn type, grass height preferences, and terrain. Both offer distinct advantages for different scenarios.

Why did people stop using reel mowers historically?

The decline in reel mower usage coincided with the advent of more technologically advanced mowing solutions. Gas-powered mowers emerged, offering the ability to cut larger lawns in significantly less time and with considerably less physical effort. Subsequently, electric mowers further enhanced convenience by eliminating the need for fuel, along with its associated smells, fumes, and maintenance mess. While these innovations offered undeniable practical benefits, they often overlooked the unique advantages and connection that manual reel mowers provide. However, reel mowers remain a fantastic and sustainable investment for many modern homeowners.

What type of maintenance does a reel mower require?

To ensure your reel mower remains in peak condition and delivers a consistently clean cut, regular maintenance is minimal but crucial. Always refer to your owner’s manual for specific manufacturer recommendations. In general, key maintenance tasks include:

• Blade Sharpening: The most important task is sharpening the blades. Depending on how frequently you mow and the type of grass, this should typically be done once or twice a year. Sharper blades ensure a clean, scissor-like cut, which is vital for lawn health.
• Cleaning: After each use, it’s a good practice to hose off any grass clippings and debris from the blades and chassis. This prevents rust and ensures smooth operation.
• Lubrication: You may want to lightly oil the blades and moving parts after cleaning, especially if storing the mower for an extended period, to further prevent rust and keep the mechanism smooth.
• Adjustments: Occasionally check for proper blade alignment and adjust the cutting height as needed.

How long should a reel mower last?

With consistent and proper maintenance, which primarily involves occasional blade sharpening and cleaning, a well-built reel mower has the potential to last a lifetime. Their simple mechanical design, without complex engines or electrical components, makes them incredibly durable and resistant to the types of failures common in motorized mowers.

Are reel mowers noisy?

No, quite the opposite. Reel mowers are celebrated for producing virtually no noise. The only sounds you typically hear are the gentle whir of the blades spinning and the distinct, satisfying snip of grass being cut. This makes them ideal for early morning or late evening mowing without disturbing neighbors, allowing for a peaceful and enjoyable lawn care experience.

What are the disadvantages of a reel mower?

While reel mowers offer numerous benefits like being eco-friendly and quiet, they do have some practical drawbacks. They perform optimally on small, relatively flat lawns with grass that is not excessively tall or dense. They may struggle significantly with uneven terrain, slopes, or overgrown, thick grass, which can require multiple passes or considerable extra effort. Since they lack a motor, mowing with a reel mower is inherently more physically demanding than using a motorized counterpart. This effort can be exacerbated if the blades are not kept consistently sharp, making the pushing action much harder and less effective.

Why You Should Trust This Review

Tyler Graham, the esteemed primary editor of The Lawn Review, brings a formidable depth of expertise and an infectious enthusiasm for all aspects of lawn care and associated tools. With a genuine passion for identifying and recommending the most effective solutions for maintaining a pristine yard, Graham has cemented his reputation as a trusted authority in the field. His insights have been featured in prominent publications like The Washington Post and hundreds of other national outlets. He meticulously combines extensive hands-on experience with rigorous, thorough research to ensure readers receive only the most reliable, practical, and actionable advice. When it comes to unbiased evaluations of lawn care equipment, particularly specialized tools like reel mowers, you can unequivocally count on Tyler Graham to cut through the marketing noise and deliver truly meaningful insights that empower your purchasing decisions.